Make sure that you new users are in the correct group I remember we hade the same problem within episerver where we had EPiServer group that was supposed to be the CommunityMembers group. Therefore we hade to change the groupname in web.config and also reflect this group in the tables where they are using the CommunityMembers group so that it said EPiServer All instead.

If i remember correctly there is something about this in the article about upgrading a site from Relate 1 to Relate 2!?

/Eric

Thanks for the clue Eric! :)

Scheduled job is now adding all created users to 'CommunityMembers'. Comment button and rating are both available. :) I just copied code from Templates\RelatePlus\CommunityModules\CommunitySecurityModule.cs:

/// <summary>
        /// Adds the created user to the community group specified in Web.config
        /// </summary>
        /// <param name="addedUser">The user</param>
        private static void DefaultSecurity_CreatedUser(IUser addedUser)
        {
            // Add user to the community members group
            IGroup group = CommunitySystem.CurrentContext.DefaultSecurity.GetGroupByName(_community_Members);
            addedUser = (IUser)addedUser.Clone();
            addedUser.Groups.Add(group);

            // Update the user
            CommunitySystem.CurrentContext.DefaultSecurity.UpdateUser(addedUser);

            // Set access rights to the newly created user
            // Access right for anonymous users
            ReadModifyRemoveAccessRights anonAccessRights = new ReadModifyRemoveAccessRights()
            {
                Read = true,
                Modify = false,
                Remove = false
            };
            EntitySecurityHandler.Instance.SetAccessRights(addedUser, AnonymousGroup, anonAccessRights);

            // Access right for community members
            ReadModifyRemoveAccessRights communityMembersAccessRights = new ReadModifyRemoveAccessRights()
            {
                Read = true,
                Modify = false,
                Remove = false
            };
            EntitySecurityHandler.Instance.SetAccessRights(addedUser, group, communityMembersAccessRights);

            // Access rights for administrators
            ReadModifyRemoveAccessRights adminAccessRights = new ReadModifyRemoveAccessRights()
            {
                Read = true,
                Modify = true,
                Remove = true
            };
            EntitySecurityHandler.Instance.SetAccessRights(addedUser, AdministratorsGroup, adminAccessRights);

            // Access rights for the added user
            ReadModifyRemoveAccessRights userAccessRights = new ReadModifyRemoveAccessRights()
            {
                Read = true,
                Modify = true,
                Remove = true
            };
            EntitySecurityHandler.Instance.SetAccessRights(addedUser, addedUser, userAccessRights);

            // Access rights for moderator
            ReadModifyRemoveAccessRights moderatorAccessRights = new ReadModifyRemoveAccessRights()
            {
                Read = true,
                Modify = true,
                Remove = true
            };
            EntitySecurityHandler.Instance.SetAccessRights(addedUser, ModeratorsGroup, moderatorAccessRights);
        }

        private static IGroup AnonymousGroup
        {
            get
            {
                return EPiServer.Common.Settings.DefaultSecurity.GetGroup(EPiServerCommonSection.Instance.SecurityElement.AnonymousGroupId);
            }
        }

        private static IGroup AdministratorsGroup
        {
            get
            {
                return SecurityHandler.Instance.GetGroupByName("Administrators");
            }
        }

        private static IGroup ModeratorsGroup
        {
            get
            {
                return SecurityHandler.Instance.GetGroupByName("CommunityModerators");
            }
        }

Glad to help :)

And thanks for the code will probably be helpfull!!