Inconsistent display when user adds duplicate items

Description

Steps to reproduce

1. Create a page having a Content Area.
2. DnD a content item to the ContentArea.
3. DnD the same content as step2 to the Content Area.
4. Change Displays as = Wide for the first added item ==> Display as of the first items ="Wide" BUT Display as of the first item = Automation on the flyout

Expected: Should be consistent
Actual: Inconsistent